rasks:

flintsredhair:

rasks replied to your post “Last Sentence Meme”

the like button wasn’t doing it for me, sorry. BUT ALSO that first wip *insert eyes emoji* is that Admiral Hennessey I am reading in the same *universe* as Vane????

that is Admiral Hennessey existing in the same universe, in the same general locale, and as you can see, NOT HAPPY about Teach’s parenting choices!

I am so here for this AU you wouldn’t believe omg PARENTS BICKERING over how their sons are raised !!! indeed

*rubs hands together* have I mentioned that I have several fics involving Hennessey and am currently in WIP status with one where he and Vane are actively working together to go save James?

asexualizing:

  • withholding information about a person’s loved one, when you KNOW and actually are the only one left who KNOWS what this loved one means to him, so you can use this information against him
  • ignoring what your partner, who has been robbed of voice and agency, wants for herself and for the people whom she cares for and were also robbed of voice and agency, because you think you know best
  • this after you’ve painted yourself as a victim of a person who has been painted as a monster for his love, because you’ve gotten close enough for him to possibly love you
  • and tried to paint him as a monster to the only person who eventually understood him, because he understood her

Silver retire bitch

rasks replied to your post “Last Sentence Meme”

the like button wasn’t doing it for me, sorry. BUT ALSO that first wip *insert eyes emoji* is that Admiral Hennessey I am reading in the same *universe* as Vane????

that is Admiral Hennessey existing in the same universe, in the same general locale, and as you can see, NOT HAPPY about Teach’s parenting choices!

rasks replied to your post “I get why the writers chose an open ending. Why they wanted to explore…”

very eloquently put and this is also why i’ve been stalling like hell when it comes to finishing s4

Honestly, I loved the last season, like I did all the seasons of Black Sails. I laughed, I cried (I cried a lot), and I just – I get why they made the choices they did, I get that they were TRYING to rip my heart out through the walls of my chest, and they did a good job of that, and one of these days I’m probably going to look back and be grateful actually that they taught me again how to be angry. That… was something I needed back so in a way I’m glad the series ended the way it did, but on the other hand – James. Oh gods, James, and Madi, my babies, my revolutionary darlings, they deserved so much better than that. They were SO CLOSE and they cared about each other so much and they. deserved. better. than that. And on some level I think I’m always going to be angry that history and Treasure Island conspired to mean that they couldn’t have what they deserved so very much.

Last Sentence Meme

I was tagged by @iwt-v, who knows that I’m weak for this meme. Thanks!

Rules: Post the last sentence you wrote, and tag as many people as there are words in that sentence.

I’m leaving the strikethroughs because I never, ever do just one sentence on this meme – it would be an exercise in futility. Also, I’ve been working on a few things at the same time, so here’s bits from each:

1. This is going to be fluff, I promise:

“Pray listen rather than interrupting,” he snaps. “I have raised James as best I was able, with the knowledge that whatever harm I have done him has been offset at least in part by the good turn I was able to do him in the process. You, on the other hand, have taken Charles from a life of hardship, and I fear that you are doing him little good by way of return, based on the simple fact that the lad would not know comfort if it were to rear up and bite him. He knows still less, I suspect, of what it is to receive a friendly suggestion rather than take an order from a superior. He does not know -”

2. The latest chapter of Reclamation:

“Motherfucking – son of a bitching -”

His cursing is muffled, but still audible, and she finds herself wincing. The shirt is stuck – plastered to him with dried blood in spots – large spots, sticking to him and undoubtedly pulling at wounds that have reopened with the past several hours’ exertion. He is not, Madi thinks, doing himself any favors, and she reaches out with one hand to touch his arm, just as Cornelius does the same.

“Stop,” they say at the same moment, and Cornelius rises.

“I will fetch some water,” he says. “Captain. Ma’am.”

“Thank you,” she says, and earns a brief, almost startled smile from Cornelius. Like most of Julius’s people, he is not used to this – to being thanked for his efforts, not yet. He will learn – Madi is determined on that point.

3. So… I kind of have a thing in the works that I’ve been wanting to do since Christmas:

She has not had chocolate – not in so very long. The thought of it does not dull her misery – the last time was with Thomas, but the kindness of the gesture is not lost on her. She attempts a smile – not, she feels, very successfully, but it seems to reassure Mrs. Wells nonetheless.

“I fear it is a long tale,” she says, and allows herself to be drawn upward and helped to the sleigh.

“A long tale means a long time by the fire, ma’am,” Robert, her fellow servant in the household, rumbles. “Let me give you hand.”

She is handed up and into the sleigh, and just for a moment – just for a second –

She squeezes her eyes shut, and imagines that it is James’ callused hand rather than Robert’s and she begins to weep. She does not stop, not for some time.

4. (Shut up, I know, I know. Too many irons in the fire) This is some belated pancake-day fluff:

“Too right I would,” the bald pirate in question answers, and sticks his head into the room again. He looks at Gates and snorts. “Remind me why you’re quartermaster and not cook?”

“Because if I had to do this all day every day, I’d poison the lot of you and then set fire to the ship,” Gates answers. “Have the lads finished bringing in the supplies?”

“Aye,” Muldoon answers with a grin. “Best hurry up with the first batch – Joji’s eyeing that sword of his, and Mr. De Groot’s getting growly.”

I’m tagging @bean-about-townn, @captainfuckingflint, @squid-inspiration, and anyone else that wants!

I get why the writers chose an open ending. Why they wanted to explore “story is true, story is untrue” concept. But I feel like Flint wasn’t really the right person for it. His story is all about unveiling of the truth. Of shading light onto the things that history tried to bury. And Silver’s story is all about not knowing the truth. “What happened to him? Was is the truth?” would’ve fitted him perfectly. I know it wasn’t possible because of TI, so they had to do it with Flint, but… meh.

I agree, Anon. I think the ultimate irony is having a character whose entire story hinges on truth be condemned to being nothing more than the stories that are told about him – it’s a tragedy that they underscore in the narrative with the stories that are told about Charles Vane, actually. Jack says to the woman he talks to in Philadelphia that Charles was one of the bravest men he’d ever known, only to be shown in no uncertain terms that it doesn’t matter what someone’s friends say of them – it only matters what their enemies say, especially when those enemies win, and that’s the very thing that James was fighting all along. That, right there, is the heart of it, and it’s why it makes it a screaming, hair-ripping, agonizing thing to see James and Thomas fall prey to the same thing

Silver, on the other hand- he’s never been anything but one story after another. He’s never actually BEEN as opposed to being SAID TO BE, if that makes any sense, and in a way it makes him even more dangerous as a character because it sort of means that we know nothing about him. He’s no more and no less than what people say about him and I think that he derives power from that. He reminds me, actually, of every dangerous, fae character that has ever walked the pages of a fantasy novel – I’m talking straight out, Goblin King kind of power that’s derived from the power that people agree to give him. Anyway – what I’m saying in a long-winded kind of way is that I agree, Anon. James Flint is meant to be about truth and justice and fighting back against the stories told about him, whereas John Silver has only ever been a story, albeit a particularly powerful one.