and yet there is still something commanding in his gaze, and in the tone of his voice.
“Governor Rogers,” he greets. “Oh good. Everyone I want to shout at in one place.”
“You’re him.” Silver’s voice, Rogers thinks once again, is a sound he would be perfectly happy never to hear again.
“I believe you told me to shut up,” he snaps. “Allow me to return the favor. Shut -” (2/)
“You’re him,” Silver repeats, and he can hear the sound of the other man grasping hold of the bars to pull himself up, the chains he is in rattling as he does so. “You’re Thomas Hamilton.”
The man in the shadows steps forward, and Rogers inhales sharply. It is not possible –
“I see James has told you something of me,” Thomas answers, and Rogers can hear his wife’s knitting needles actually cease their clacking for a moment. Everything goes still, and then – (3/)
“I can explain,” Silver starts, and Thomas snorts. He is, Rogers thinks, different, somehow, than he had pictured. There is an edge to Thomas Hamilton – one that Rogers could not have anticipated, and against all odds, he seems to recognize it where Long John Silver patently does not. (4/)
Experience, perhaps – he had had the misfortune of encountering Alfred Hamilton once, and only once, and suddenly he is reminded that Thomas, for all that he had been accounted a good man by those who knew him, is also Alfred’s son. Rogers sits up straighter, gaze snapping toward Silver, suddenly awake and alert and quite completely terrified. “Shut up,” Rogers hisses. “For the love of God -”(5/)
“Shut up,” Rogers hisses. “For the love of God -” “I very much doubt that,” Thomas addresses Silver directly, and somehow – somehow, Rogers knows that he will not be sharing these cells with the ruffian on the other side of the bars for much longer. “Please, though – do tell me why you thought you could abuse and sell the man I love and not have me come for your head.” For the fanfic commentary thing?
ooooh, I am so excited that you’ve chosen this for fic commentary!
I really, really, really love this section. Rogers POV is one that I did NOT expect to have in this fic, but I realized that an outside perspective on Thomas would actually be really useful, because it gives us an idea of what the past ten years has done to Thomas in terms of how he’s perceived by others. It also gives us an idea of how Thomas is going to be seen by people in the next chapter – what it is that Thomas’ cousin Archibald sees when he looks at Thomas, and what Hennessey sees, because the Thomas who has come back from that plantation is not the Thomas that went away and I think it’s important to acknowledge that. He’s angry, here – really, absolutely furious, and I wanted to show everyone what an angry Thomas Hamilton looks like now that we’ve also seen frightened Thomas and joyful Thomas and a host of other Thomases that are equally related to the trauma he’s suffered and his sudden, unexpected removal from that situation.
As to Rogers and Silver and what’s going on with them emotionally – well, for starters, they hate each other. They were never going to do anything else, really – Silver’s a talker and Rogers is raving at ghost!Eleanor, and so I want everyone to imagine here that these two have been snarking at each other for days and driving everyone else, their guards included, absolutely mad. I’d imagine the guards are quite happy to let Thomas in – they’re hoping he can bring sanity or at least take a request to Madi for earplugs!
In all honesty, though, when Thomas reads him the riot act, I think Silver’s just seen the specter of what he was going to do to James and it’s really brought home to him that what he planned was horrifying. It is in no way a mercy – as Thomas tells him, there’s nothing about that plantation that is anything less than hard and soul-crushing and dangerous, and that’s the fate that Silver planned to hand James over to. That’s what Thomas has come through, and this is also Thomas saying to Silver and Rogers too, “I know what you’ve done to my husband. It stops now, if I have to fucking break you to pieces psychologically to make it stop.” Silver clings to denial but ultimately breaks at least a bit. Rogers, though – I think what Thomas says to Silver actually frightens Rogers quite significantly, because he sees in Thomas what he himself could become. This is Rogers’ moment of realizing what England does to men who try to change her even by legal means – what she does even to those with great privilege if they step out of line and it scares the shit out of him. He’s come from a place of thinking like a lot of rich men – that the pirates just made all the wrong choices in life to end up where they are, and Thomas is proof to the contrary. He’s proof that a man can do everything right – everything Rogers himself has done as far as working within the law – and still end up a slave, shoulders no longer straight, hands twitching for work to do, and towering anger that’s strong enough to topple empires included. I’m setting a deliberate contrast in this scene, between Silver who lies to himself regularly and so allows any guilt he feels at his actions to slide away and Rogers who has been screaming apologies to his dead wife and now sees in full just what it is that his enemies have been fighting against without any kind of filter between him and that horrifying realization that he’s been wrong.