Re the other anon. Here’s my stance on the Savannah thing, from almost a year ago. So if Treasure Island is not canon and a story based on stories and so on, that’s just based on the pirate’s last info that he would have been in Savannah, so even if parts of TI are true then that’s what that info would have been based off. Meanwhile they’re off staging a revolution with Madi somewhere

That sounds like a good take on it to me, Anon! I just can’t picture the Madi that I know bowing down and letting that happen to her friend – I can’t. She and James understood each other, they respected each other, they had each other’s back – he saved her life, for fuck’s sake, which is not to say that she owes him for doing the right thing, but it’s to say that there’s a lot more between them than just being allies in the same war. I like to think that she went up to the cliff to tell Silver that if he won’t leave her island, then she will, and then went to go find James and Thomas, because I’m not sure how she could bear to do anything else. I know I certainly couldn’t.