rasks replied to your post “I get why the writers chose an open ending. Why they wanted to explore…”

very eloquently put and this is also why i’ve been stalling like hell when it comes to finishing s4

Honestly, I loved the last season, like I did all the seasons of Black Sails. I laughed, I cried (I cried a lot), and I just – I get why they made the choices they did, I get that they were TRYING to rip my heart out through the walls of my chest, and they did a good job of that, and one of these days I’m probably going to look back and be grateful actually that they taught me again how to be angry. That… was something I needed back so in a way I’m glad the series ended the way it did, but on the other hand – James. Oh gods, James, and Madi, my babies, my revolutionary darlings, they deserved so much better than that. They were SO CLOSE and they cared about each other so much and they. deserved. better. than that. And on some level I think I’m always going to be angry that history and Treasure Island conspired to mean that they couldn’t have what they deserved so very much.